Discussion:
the concept of uncountable nouns
(时间太久无法回复)
D***@kkcity.com.tw
2007-06-23 12:28:58 UTC
Permalink
Emperor penguins have interesting egg-laying habits
^^^
My question is why it cannot be the form " habit," but must be plural?

isn't the word "habit" here to show their usual behaviour? if it were, it

should be a single form, isn't it?
--
┌─────◆KKCITY◆─────┐  KKBOX◤歌名╱歌手╱歌詞╱專輯◢搜尋 
│ bbs.kkcity.com.tw │   ★ http://www.kkbox.com.tw ★
└──《From:219.86.100.146 》──┘ 超過100家唱片公司合法授權 音樂盡情下載
--
DJ
2007-06-23 12:52:05 UTC
Permalink
Post by D***@kkcity.com.tw
Emperor penguins have interesting egg-laying habits
^^^
My question is why it cannot be the form " habit," but must be plural?
isn't the word "habit" here to show their usual behaviour? if it were, it
should be a single form, isn't it?
According to Longman ONLINE, "habit" can be a countable or uncountable
noun. So, the question here is how many different kinds of behavior
patterns you know regarding emperor penguins' egg-laying habits. In
other words, the author knows there're more than one egg-laying habits,
and that's why he wrote it that way. Of course, if you are so sure
there's only one single kind of egg-laying habit, then, yeah, go ahead
and write "habit".
DJ
2007-06-23 13:01:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by DJ
other words, the author knows there're more than one egg-laying habits,
other words, the author knows there's more than one egg-laying habit,
這是一首得獎的小情歌
2007-06-25 22:28:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by D***@kkcity.com.tw
Emperor penguins have interesting egg-laying habits
^^^
My question is why it cannot be the form " habit," but must be plural?
No, it could be singular.
Emperor penguins have an interesting egg-laying habit.
Post by D***@kkcity.com.tw
isn't the word "habit" here to show their usual behaviour? if it were, it
should be a single form, isn't it?
Why? Maybe they have more than one interesting egg-laying habit.

--
 ◢██◤ Origin: 交大外文 眾聲喧嘩 2.0 bbs.fl.nctu.edu.tw
◢██◤◢ Author: oasis 從 jay.Dorm-GD2.NCTU.edu.tw 發表
≡≡≡◢

Loading...